Haunted St Augustine – 19 Creepy Places You Need To See!
St. Augustine is widely considered one of the most haunted cities in America. Founded in 1565, the city’s centuries of war, disease, piracy, executions, and tragedy have produced countless ghost stories that continue to attract paranormal investigators and curious travelers today. For anyone interested in exploring haunted St. Augustine, the city’s rich history and eerie legends make it one of the best paranormal destinations in the country.
From the St. Augustine Lighthouse to the Old Jail and Castillo de San Marcos, these are the most haunted places in St. Augustine that you can visit for yourself.
Discovering Haunted St Augustine
Why Is St. Augustine So Haunted?
There is a reason so many people consider St. Augustine one of the most haunted cities in America. Founded in 1565, it is the oldest continuously occupied European settlement in the United States, giving it more than four centuries of history filled with conflict, hardship, and tragedy.
Throughout the Spanish colonial era, the city endured battles for control of Florida, attacks from rival European powers, and violent clashes that left lasting scars on the community. Many paranormal enthusiasts believe these events created the perfect conditions for the ghost stories and unexplained encounters that continue to be reported today.
Beyond warfare, St. Augustine’s residents faced numerous challenges, including devastating disease outbreaks, harsh living conditions, and frequent pirate attacks along Florida’s coast. The city’s historic cemeteries, military fortifications, and centuries-old buildings serve as reminders of the many lives lost throughout its history.
During the Civil War, St. Augustine once again found itself caught in a period of uncertainty and occupation, adding another layer to its already complex past.
Whether you believe in ghosts or not, the city’s long history of conflict, loss, and survival helps explain why haunted St. Augustine has become a destination for paranormal investigators and curious visitors from around the world.
Why Visit Haunted St Augustine?
Exploring haunted St. Augustine offers more than just a fright; it’s a chance to dive deep into the rich history of the oldest city in the United States. The blend of cobblestone streets, colonial architecture, and a storied past creates a backdrop ripe for ghostly tales.
Venturing into sites like the St. Augustine Lighthouse or the Old Jail not only promises spine-tingling moments but also an educational glimpse into the city’s past. This mix of history and hauntings provides diverse content opportunities to captivate readers.
Moreover, haunted St. Augustine’s unique charm and mystery offer the perfect setting to inspire readers to explore beyond the usual tourist spots, igniting their sense of adventure and curiosity.
Preparing for Your Spooky Adventure
Before setting off on your haunted St. Augustine adventure, it’s wise to plan ahead for a seamless experience.
👻 Start by researching the city’s most famous haunted sites—like the St. Augustine Lighthouse and the Old Jail—and decide which ones intrigue you the most. Each location offers different tours, often led by knowledgeable guides who share insights and eerie tales.
👻 Dress comfortably, as you might be walking or standing for extended periods, especially during ghost tours that often take place in the evening. It’s also a good idea to bring a small flashlight, as some areas can be dimly lit.
Historic Landmarks
1. Castillo de San Marcos
No visit to haunted St. Augustine is complete without exploring Castillo de San Marcos. Built by the Spanish between 1672 and 1695, this massive coquina stone fortress is the oldest masonry fort in the continental United States. Designed to protect St. Augustine and vital Atlantic trade routes, the fort’s unique walls, made from compressed seashells, were remarkably effective at absorbing cannon fire during attacks.
Today, the Castillo stands as a National Monument overlooking Matanzas Bay, attracting visitors eager to experience one of the city’s most iconic historic landmarks. During my visit, it was easy to understand why the fort has become one of the most famous haunted locations in St. Augustine. Walking through the dark casemates and along the weathered ramparts, the atmosphere feels heavy with centuries of warfare, imprisonment, and loss.
One of the most well-known ghost stories associated with the Castillo involves Osceola, the legendary Seminole leader who managed to evade capture during the Second Seminole War. In 1837, however, he was lured under a false flag of truce and imprisoned at the fort, then known as Fort Marion, along with hundreds of his followers.
Although Osceola was already in poor health, he received medical treatment from Dr. Frederick Weedon, and the two reportedly developed a friendship. After Osceola’s death, however, Dr. Weedon committed an act many considered both shocking and disrespectful by removing Osceola’s head and preserving it in a jar.
This disturbing chapter of the fort’s history has given rise to one of its most enduring legends: reports of a headless shadow figure wandering the grounds at night. Other visitors and paranormal investigators have reported hearing phantom footsteps, unexplained voices, and seeing shadowy apparitions believed to be former soldiers, prisoners, and Native American captives who once suffered within the fortress walls.
While Castillo de San Marcos is part of a public park, there is an admission fee to enter the fort itself. The site does not offer dedicated ghost tours, either during the day or at night, although many St. Augustine ghost tours stop outside the landmark and share its haunted history. Visitors should also be aware that no tours are permitted inside the fort after dark due to safety restrictions. If you want to explore the interior and experience its eerie atmosphere firsthand, you’ll need to visit during regular daytime operating hours.
2. Flagler College
One of the most beautiful and intriguing stops on any haunted St. Augustine itinerary is Flagler College, housed within the former Ponce de León Hotel. Built in 1888 by railroad tycoon Henry Flagler, the lavish hotel was designed to attract wealthy travelers to Florida’s oldest city.
During my visit, it was impossible not to be impressed by the Spanish Renaissance architecture, grand rotundas, intricate mosaics, and stunning Tiffany stained-glass windows. While the building now serves as a liberal arts college, many believe the spirits of its past residents never truly checked out.
The most famous ghost stories surrounding Flagler College involve Henry Flagler and his second wife, Ida Alice Flagler. According to local legend, Flagler was a deeply superstitious man who requested that every door and window in his buildings be left open during his funeral so his spirit could pass freely into the afterlife. While his wishes were reportedly honored, some claim a janitor accidentally closed several windows inside the hotel. Paranormal enthusiasts speculate that this mistake trapped Flagler’s spirit within the building he worked so hard to create.
Others believe his wife Ida Alice remains there as well. Their marriage was troubled, and after years of declining mental health, Ida was committed to an institution where she remained until her death. Many ghost hunters believe her spirit lingers in the former hotel, unable to move on from the heartbreak and injustice she endured. Visitors and students have reported seeing a mysterious apparition known as the “Woman in Black,” widely believed to be Ida Alice wandering the halls.
Another chilling legend involves one of Flagler’s alleged mistresses, an actress who was reportedly hidden from his wife inside a fourth-floor room lined entirely with mirrors. The room is said to have functioned as a psychomanteum, a chamber used for séances and attempts to communicate with the dead. According to local lore, something tragic occurred during that encounter, and the actress later hanged herself from a chandelier. Whether the story is fact or folklore, students and staff continue to report unexplained footsteps, flickering lights, cold spots, shadow figures, and the unsettling feeling of being watched throughout the historic building.
While Flagler College offers public tours of its remarkable architecture and history, the official tours do not discuss the hauntings. Fortunately, many St. Augustine ghost tours stop outside the college to share the building’s darker legends and paranormal reputation.
3. Old City Gates
Constructed in the early 1800s as part of St. Augustine’s defensive walls, the Old City Gates once controlled access to the city after dark. Travelers, soldiers, and merchants passed through these gates for generations, and some believe not all of them ever truly left.
Today, the gates are a popular historical landmark, greeting visitors at the entrance to the historic district. However, their long history has also made them the subject of several local ghost stories. One of the most well-known legends involves a young girl named Elizabeth, who is said to haunt the area surrounding the gates.
According to local lore, Elizabeth was a victim of the devastating yellow fever epidemic of 1821. Her body was reportedly discovered near the columns of the Old City Gates and went unclaimed. Like many others who perished during the outbreak, she was buried in an unmarked grave at nearby Huguenot Cemetery.
Some visitors claim to have seen the apparition of a young girl dressed in white near the gates at night, leading many to believe Elizabeth’s spirit still wanders the area centuries later.
4. The Old Wooden Schoolhouse
The Oldest Wooden School House dates back to the early 18th century and is one of St. Augustine’s most recognizable historic attractions. Legend suggests that former students and teachers may still linger within the building.
Guests have reported hearing children’s laughter when no one else is present, along with unexplained creaks and movement inside the structure. While skeptics point to the age of the building, paranormal enthusiasts believe these experiences may be evidence of spirits tied to the school’s long history.
5. The Segui-Kirby Smith House
The Segui-Kirby House is one of St. Augustine’s oldest surviving residences and has witnessed centuries of changing ownership and historical events. Numerous stories surround the property, including reports of unexplained sounds and sightings of apparitions near the home.
Some believe former residents remain attached to the house, while others attribute the activity to the property’s deep colonial roots. Its long history makes it a popular stop on many ghost tours.
6. Don Pedro Horruytiner House
Named after a former Spanish governor of Florida, the Don Pedro Horruytiner House is associated with several paranormal legends. Visitors have reported hearing disembodied voices and experiencing sudden cold spots throughout the historic property.
Ghost tour guides often share stories of shadow figures appearing near windows and hallways. Whether these encounters are genuine hauntings or the product of centuries of local folklore, the house remains one of the city’s most mysterious locations.
Cemeteries
7. Tolomato Cemetery
Tolomato Cemetery is widely considered one of the most haunted cemeteries in Florida. Established on the site of a former Native American mission, the cemetery contains the graves of many of St. Augustine’s earliest residents.
One of the most famous legends involves the ghost of a young girl in a blue dress. Witnesses claim to have seen her wandering among the gravestones before vanishing without explanation. Visitors also report strange lights, whispers, and an overwhelming sense of being watched.
Many believe them to be the ghosts of Father Varela and Bishop Verot, even though the two men are no longer buried in this cemetery. Maybe their spirits don’t appreciate their eternal sleep being disturbed?
There is another story of a spectral bride who overwhelms those who see her so much they begin to cry.
Then there is the story of a young boy who can frequently be found playing on a tree branch toward the ground’s entrance. This spirit might be reliving its last moments, as it’s said the boy died by falling from the tree.
8. Huguenot Cemetery
Established in 1821 during a yellow fever outbreak, Huguenot Cemetery became the final resting place for many victims of disease and hardship. The tragic circumstances surrounding the cemetery’s creation have led to numerous reports of paranormal activity.
Ghost hunters frequently describe seeing apparitions among the tombstones and hearing unexplained voices after dark. Some visitors claim they have captured mysterious figures in photographs taken throughout the cemetery.
In 1882, Judge John B. Stickney died during a yellow fever epidemic and was buried in the mostly protestant graveyard. It was intended that his body was to be exhumed at a later date so that his family could rebury him.
Upon unearthing the casket, they discovered several valuables, including the judge’s gold teeth, had been stolen. This might explain why many have seen the figure of a man looking for something.
Hotels
9. Casa Monica Resort & Spa
Originally opened in 1888, Casa Monica has welcomed guests for more than a century. Along with luxury accommodations, the historic hotel has accumulated its share of ghost stories.
Guests have reported hearing voices in empty rooms, witnessing unexplained movement, and encountering shadowy figures in hallways. Some believe former guests who once enjoyed the grand hotel never truly checked out.
Museums
10. Lightner Museum
Housed within the former Alcazar Hotel, the Lightner Museum is one of St. Augustine’s most beautiful and reportedly haunted buildings. During its years as a luxury resort, thousands of visitors passed through its halls.
Inside, it boasts an eclectic collection ranging from fine art and Victorian-era furnishings to Tiffany glass and curiosities from the 19th century. The museum’s exhibits are spread across four floors, offering a rich exploration of decorative arts and historical objects.
Just like any other building with history, many people believe the building is haunted, either by hotel guests who still roam the building or by spirits attached to the various antiques and collectibles which make up the museum’s collection.
The indoor pool, which now houses Cafe Alcazar, is thought to especially be a hot spot of activity as guests and employees have reported hearing the murmurs of disembodied voices echoing throughout or the sound of splashing water.
11. Ripley’s Believe It or Not
Ripley’s Believe It or Not in St. Augustine offers a quirky and fascinating exploration of the odd and unusual. Housed in the historic Warden Castle, this museum features a vast array of exhibits showcasing bizarre artifacts, unusual art, and strange stories from around the world.
From shrunken heads and optical illusions to interactive displays, Ripley’s promises an entertaining adventure for visitors of all ages. The building itself, with its castle-like architecture, adds to the allure, making it a unique attraction within the city.
Many come here looking for a unique tour, not realizing it’s one of the most haunted places in Saint Augustine!
The Ripley’s Believe It or Not! Museum is located in the Warden Castle. Built in 1887 by William G. Warden, he was a partner of Henry Flagler. In 1941, Norton Baskin purchased the home and converted it into a hotel. Three years later, on Sunday, April 23, 1944, a fire erupted leaving behind two casualties.
Bette Richeson, who stayed in Room 17, the Theatre Room today, and Ruth Pickering, a friend of the hotel owners, was staying in the upstairs penthouse apartment which is used as an attic now. They were the victims of the fire, or were they?
When the women were found, their bodies were in dry bathtubs with towels around their necks. It is also reported that the women did not know each other, but a mysterious apparition known as “Mr.X” seems to have known them both.
Rumor has it the fire was just a cover up for the murders and according to EMF readings, the women are still afraid of this shadow figure today.
12. Ximenez-Fatio House Museum
The Ximenez-Fatio House Museum is a well-preserved piece of Florida’s early history, offering insight into 19th-century life in St. Augustine. Built in 1798 by Spanish merchant Andres Ximenez, the house later became a boarding house run by women, providing a unique perspective on the role of women in the early tourism industry.
Today, it stands as one of the best-preserved examples of Second Spanish Period architecture. Visitors can explore authentically furnished rooms and learn about the lives of those who lived and worked there.
In the 1800s, it was common for doctors to recommend those who suffered from tuberculosis in northern states to head south. It was believed a warm climate would promote better health and ease their ailments.
One of the rooms in the house is referred to as a “Frail Lady Room”. Like a fainting room, such an area was used to allow someone who was not feeling well or short of breath some privacy. It was recorded at least one death accord in this room.
After learning of a few deaths that took place inside the home, Archivist Taryn Rodriguez-Boette dug deeper into the Ximenez-Fatio property. In total, there were thirteen.
Between the numerous deaths, and all of those who owned the home, whoever roams the halls has night has not been completely identified. Between tales of a ghostly shade in a mirror, an original item to the house, to the spirit of a little girl named Miss Madison, it could be just about any of them who still have a story to tell.
13. Old Jail Museum
The Old Jail Museum in St. Augustine offers visitors a fascinating glimpse into the harsh realities of early 20th-century incarceration. Built in 1891, the jail was designed to blend with the city’s Spanish Renaissance Revival architecture, disguising its true purpose.
Now a museum, it provides insight into the lives of its notorious inmates and the conditions they endured. The guided tours, often led by costumed actors, bring history to life with stories of daring escapes and infamous criminals.
Henry Flagler, a prominent figure in St. Augustine history, wanted to ensure a safe and pleasant environment for his hotel patrons. That is why when he could see the original jailhouse from his hotel, he offered $10,000 to the city to rebuild the jail in another location.
Since St. Augustine was growing as a tourist destination, it was important to Flagler that the exterior appearance wouldn’t disrupt the ma atmosphere. It was almost unrecognizable as a jail apart from the barred windows. But what happened inside, was a completely different story.
The jail served the city of St. Augustine from 1891 to 1953. While it held some of the most violent criminals, many were given what could be seen as life sentences for simply being poor and unwanted. We say life sentences because many died during their stay due to the harsh treatment and conditions.
Prisoners were crammed into cells and performed hard labor on the prison grounds. The men worked the fields, women would work in the kitchens and clean. The abuse between inmates and the guards were astounding.
Many claim they can still hear the barking of prison dogs at night, having their arms or legs grabbed at, or banging on the cell walls. Do you dare to sit in The Solitary Cell, where many claimed to have seen a crawling shadowed apparition come at them?
👻➡️Check out their night time tour, the only one that gets you inside the jail! Click here!
14. Saint Augustine Lighthouse and Maritime Museum
The Saint Augustine Lighthouse and Maritime Museum stands as a beacon of maritime history and intrigue. Towering 165 feet above Anastasia Island, the lighthouse offers breathtaking views of Florida’s coastline and a compelling glimpse into the region’s seafaring past.
The museum preserves artifacts and stories from the area’s maritime heritage, including shipwreck discoveries and tales of lighthouse keepers who braved storms and isolation. Visitors can climb the lighthouse’s 219 steps to enjoy panoramic views and explore exhibits that delve into the science of nautical navigation and the daily lives of lighthouse keepers.
The lighthouse’s haunted history begins with the death of three young girls from 1873. Today, it is said you can still hear the sounds of giggling and footsteps. The tragedy that befell the children of Hezekiah H. Pittee, superintendent of lighthouse construction from 1871 to 74, was during the construction of the original tower.
The five children, Pittee’s four children: Mary, Eliza, Edward and Carrie, and another little girl who was possibly the daughter of one of the workers, were playing on a supply cart that ran on the tracks. The cart hit the gate and the children fell into nearby water. The two youngest children, Edward and Carrie Pittee survived, but the oldest, Eliza and Mary, and the unknown girl drowned.
Another reported death was of Light Keeper Joseph Andreu who died on Dec. 5, 1859. He was painting the tower when the scaffolding failed, and he fell about 60 feet.
Numerous ghost hunter groups have come to the light house to confirm its paranormal activity including the Syfy television series Ghost Hunters and featured on many paranormal series and documentaries. No wonder this is considered one of the most haunted places in Saint Augustine!
👻➡️The St. Augustine Lighthouse offers a variety of tours, including the Dark of the Moon Ghost Tour. Check out their site here!
15. Spanish Military Hospital
The Spanish Military Hospital Museum offers a captivating look into the medical practices of the Spanish colonial period in St. Augustine. Located on the original site of a military hospital from the Second Spanish Period, this museum provides a unique historical experience.
Visitors can explore the reconstructed hospital building, where they learn about the medical treatments and surgeries performed in the 18th century. Guided tours feature demonstrations of colonial medical techniques, offering insight into the challenges faced by doctors and patients alike.
Hospitals, whether old and abandoned or recently built, leave you with an overwhelming sensation. Many enter with an illness, and some do not leave.
The Spanish Military hospital is no different, other than being one of the oldest hospitals in Florida. Having such a history and coming from a time where many doctors lacked true medical knowledge, we can only imagine the pain and suffering of patients.
During repairs in 1821 is when the city had to replace the water lines that ran under the building, workers discovered human bones. It was discovered the remains belonged to the Timucuan natives and the hospital sat on a burial ground.
Many seem to have an overwhelming feeling when coming to the hospital. Do the moans and cries belong to the disturbed natives? Or to the many patients of the hospital?
🚎➡️Want a quick and easy way to navigate through the most haunted places of Saint Augustine? Try the hop on and off trolley!
Click here to purchase tickets!
Bed and Breakfasts
16. St. Francis Inn
The St. Francis Inn, nestled in the historic district of St. Augustine, offers a charming blend of history and hospitality. Dating back to 1791, this inn is one of the oldest in the city, exuding the charm of a bygone era with its coquina stone walls and period furnishings.
Guests are greeted with a warm atmosphere, complete with cozy rooms and modern amenities. The inn’s beautiful courtyard garden and inviting common areas provide perfect spots for relaxation. Known for its friendly service and homemade breakfast, the St. Francis Inn ensures a memorable stay.
The St. Francis Inn does not try to hide the tragic love story that took place here. Some believe that the ghost of a young house servant, Lily, haunts one of the bedrooms on the third floor hence it being named “Lily’s Room”.
Major William Hardee, who owned the Inn during the middle of the 19th century, had a nephew come visit him. The nephew met and fell in love with Lily.
When the uncle walked in on them, one of two things happened. He either killed Lily and his nephew jumped from the third story window out of grief and guilt, or the uncle simply made her leave, and out of depression, the nephew still killed himself.
Many guests and staff alike have seen a male and female apparition, usually seeing someone in a white dress. Moved belongings, or stranger, belongings filled with water have been found in other places.
Aside from Lily’s Room; Anna’s Room, Elizabeth’s Suite, or Garcia Suite also have activity. They even have a “Paranormal Paranoia Package” you can add onto your room to receive two books on haunted places in Saint Augustine, reservations for a ghost tour and t-shirts as well as making sure you get booked in one of their haunted rooms.
17. Casablanca Inn
Casablanca Inn, situated along the scenic Matanzas Bay, is a St. Augustine landmark known for its elegant charm and storied past. Built in 1914, this Mediterranean Revival-style inn offers guests a luxurious stay with its beautifully appointed rooms and sweeping views of the waterfront.
Each room is uniquely decorated, blending historic touches with modern comforts. The inn’s veranda and courtyard are perfect for enjoying a leisurely breakfast or evening cocktails, providing a tranquil retreat from the bustling city. Casablanca Inn is also known for its ghostly tales, with many guests reporting supernatural encounters, adding an air of mystery to its allure.
The Casablanca Inn used to be the “The Matanzas Hotel” and was constructed in 1914. The Casablanca Inn played a major role during the prohibition era of the 1920’s. The Inn’s original operator Ms. Bradshaw helped bootleggers smuggle alcohol into the bay.
On nights when ships were scheduled to bring in their illegal cargo, Ms. Bradshaw would take a lantern up to the second story window and wave it back and forth to notify the bootlegger’s ships that no government officials or law enforcement were in the area. It is said that she was greatly compensated for helping facilitate these imports.
18. Casa de Suenos
Casa de Suenos, translating to “House of Dreams,” is a delightful bed and breakfast nestled in the heart of St. Augustine. This charming inn combines the warmth of Southern hospitality with the allure of historic elegance. Each room is thoughtfully designed with comfort in mind, offering a cozy retreat for guests.
The inn’s inviting atmosphere is complemented by personalized service, a delicious homemade breakfast, and afternoon treats. Located just steps away from the city’s historic attractions, Casa de Suenos provides an ideal base for exploring St. Augustine’s rich history and vibrant culture.
Like many historic properties in the area, is rumored to have its own paranormal activity. St. Augustine, known as one of the oldest cities in the U.S., has a long history of ghost stories and hauntings. Guests staying at Casa de Suenos have occasionally reported unexplained occurrences, including strange noises, lights flickering, and the sense of a presence in the rooms.
19. Casa de Solana
Casa de Solana, established in the 18th century, is one of the oldest inns in St. Augustine and every bit as charming. Each of its rooms exudes a romantic ambiance, perfect for couples seeking a quaint getaway. The inn blends vintage decor and contemporary comfort seamlessly, making for a cozy and unique stay to its guests.
Equally mesmerising are the inn’s lush outdoor spaces, where patrons can relax amidst verdant greenery and beautiful flowers.
As one of the oldest properties in the city, dating back to the early 1700s, it has a long history that lends itself to ghostly legends. Guests and staff have reported a range of paranormal activities, including unexplained footsteps, strange noises, and sightings of apparitions, particularly in certain rooms like the “Sanchez Suite”.
One of the most commonly shared stories involves the spirit of a woman in period clothing, believed to be one of the house’s early residents, who is occasionally seen wandering the premises. The inn’s connection to St. Augustine’s deep history makes it a popular destination for those interested in the supernatural.
20. The Prince of Wales
The Prince of Wales Bed and Breakfast occupies a historic Victorian home with a reputation for unexplained activity. Guests have reported hearing footsteps in empty hallways and sensing unseen presences throughout the property.
The building’s age and rich history have contributed to numerous local legends that continue to attract paranormal enthusiasts.
Restaurants and Bars
21. Stogies Cigar Bar and Listening Room
Stogies Cigar Bar and Listening Room in St. Augustine is a haven for cigar aficionados and music lovers alike. Located in a quaint, historic building, Stogies offers a cozy ambiance where patrons can unwind with a fine cigar and enjoy live music.
The bar boasts an extensive selection of cigars from around the world, paired with a diverse menu of craft beers, wines, and spirits. The warm, inviting interior, complete with comfortable seating and exposed brick walls, creates the perfect setting for relaxation and camaraderie.
22. O.C. White’s Restaurant
O.C. White’s Restaurant, located in a historic 1790s structure in St. Augustine, offers diners a delightful blend of history and culinary excellence. Known for its charming ambiance and Southern hospitality, the restaurant serves a diverse menu featuring fresh seafood, hearty steaks, and classic Southern dishes.
The outdoor patio, under a canopy of twinkling lights and lush greenery, provides a picturesque setting for a leisurely meal. Inside, the restaurant’s historic charm is enhanced by period furnishings and a cozy fireplace.
When O.C. White’s was still the Worth Mansion, it was struck by a fire and the third floor was damaged. Margaret’s portrait was left untouched by the flames.
Many suggest that Margaret was protecting the remains of her residence. Customers and staff also claim that she roams the restaurant setting and unsetting tables.
There is also a man often spotted in the mirror of the men’s restroom wearing a bowling hat. Margaret left it to her son-in-law, Colonel John T. Sprague so her daughter could continue to live there. Many believe the man in the mirror to be him.
While you may want to sit out in the garden to enjoy the live music with your food, you might want to request a table inside if you want to catch a glimpse of the spirits. We recommend getting one of their unique cocktails and trying to grab a seat for Sunday Brunch.
23. Harry’s Seafood Bar and Grille
Harry’s Seafood Bar and Grille, situated in the heart of St. Augustine, is a culinary destination that brings the flavors of New Orleans to Florida’s coast. Located in a historic building with a charming courtyard, Harry’s offers a vibrant dining experience with its fusion of Southern, Cajun, and Creole cuisines.
The menu features flavorful dishes such as jambalaya, shrimp étouffée, and po’boys, alongside fresh seafood and house specialties. Guests can enjoy their meals in the cozy interior or the lush, atmospheric courtyard, which often hosts live music.
This private residence was once owned by Juana Navarro who later married and has nine children. One of them was named Catalina.
In 1764, just 11 years old, Catalina and her family were forced to evacuate to Cuba when Florida became an English Colony. When the British were forced out twenty years later, Catalina and her family returned to claim the estate that was once theirs.
On April 12th, 1887, a fire swept through St. Augustine and the building was one of many lost in the blaze. Bridget Barry, a maid, lost her life by running back into the servants’ quarters to retrieve what few belongings she had. This might be why her spirit is said to still haunt the building today.
With all the intense activity you will find inside this restaurant, it definitely makes our list of the most haunted places in Saint Augustine.
24. The Scarlett House
Tucked away on Hypolita Street, The Scarlett House is one of the lesser-known stops on a haunted St. Augustine itinerary, but many locals believe it deserves far more attention.
Formerly known as Scarlett O’Hara’s, the popular pub occupies a historic Victorian-era building that has been part of downtown St. Augustine’s landscape for generations. While visitors often stop in for food, drinks, and live music, many leave having heard stories about unexplained activity that has given the establishment a haunted reputation.
Employees and patrons have reported hearing unexplained footsteps, seeing shadowy figures move through empty rooms, and experiencing the unsettling feeling that someone is watching them from just out of sight.
The most famous ghost associated with the building is said to be Mr. Colee, a former resident whose spirit allegedly never left the property. According to local legend, Mr. Colee drowned in a bathtub inside the building under mysterious circumstances. Since his death, staff members have reported strange occurrences believed to be connected to him, including objects moving on their own, unexplained noises coming from upstairs, and sightings of a male apparition wandering through the historic structure.
Some employees claim they have felt an unseen presence standing beside them when the building should have been empty, while others have reported hearing footsteps when no one else was around.
Best Ghost Tours in St. Augustine
One of the best ways to experience haunted St. Augustine is by joining a ghost tour. From family-friendly walking tours to late-night paranormal investigations inside some of the city’s most notorious haunted locations, there is a tour for every type of traveler. Whether you’re looking for spooky stories, haunted pub crawls, or hands-on ghost hunting experiences, these are the best ghost tours in St. Augustine.
St. Augustine Ghost Tour
A Ghostly Encounter
This walking tour explores some of the city’s most haunted landmarks while sharing local legends, ghost sightings, and centuries of paranormal history. Guides focus on storytelling and eyewitness accounts, making it a great introduction to haunted St. Augustine.
➡️ Book Your Tour Here! 👻⬅️
Ghost Tour of St. Augustine: The Original Haunted History Tour
Spyglass Tours
This tour blends documented history with local ghost stories, creating an experience that appeals to both history buffs and paranormal enthusiasts. Visitors explore some of the oldest streets in America while learning about the spirits said to haunt them.
➡️ Book Your Tour Here! 👻⬅️
Family Friendly Ghost Tour of St. Augustine
Seaside Adventures
Perfect for families with younger children, this tour shares spooky stories without the graphic details often found on traditional ghost tours. It’s a fun way for kids and adults alike to learn about St. Augustine’s haunted history.
➡️ Book Your Tour Here! 👻⬅️
Old Jail After Dark Paranormal Experience
Historic Tours of America
Unlike standard ghost tours, this experience allows guests to investigate the infamous Old Jail after hours. Participants use paranormal investigation equipment while exploring one of the most haunted locations in St. Augustine.
➡️ Book Your Tour Here! 👻⬅️
Haunted Saint Augustine: A Paranormal Investigation
GhoSt Augustine
Designed for serious ghost hunters, this tour goes beyond storytelling and introduces guests to paranormal investigation techniques and equipment. Participants may have the opportunity to conduct real-time investigations at reportedly haunted locations throughout the city.
➡️ Book Your Tour Here! 👻⬅️
Guardian Angels of St. Augustine Walking Tour
No 9 Tours
Rather than focusing solely on hauntings, this unique tour explores the legends of guardian angels, miracles, and spiritual encounters connected to St. Augustine’s history. It offers a fascinating look at the city’s supernatural side from a different perspective.
➡️ Book Your Tour Here! 👻⬅️
Ancient City Tarot Walk and Ghost Stroll in St. Augustine
No 9 Tours
This unique experience combines ghost stories, local history, and tarot readings into one memorable evening. Guests explore the historic district while learning about the city’s paranormal legends and mystical traditions.
➡️ Book Your Tour Here! 👻⬅️
The Ghoulish Gourmet Haunted Food Tour
Haunting Hour St. Augustine
Food and ghosts come together on this tour that pairs local cuisine with tales of haunted restaurants, historic buildings, and paranormal encounters. Along the way, guests enjoy tastings while discovering the darker side of St. Augustine’s culinary scene.
➡️ Book Your Tour Here! 👻⬅️
St. Augustine Haunted Pub Crawl
Ghost City Tours
This adults-only experience combines haunted history with visits to some of St. Augustine’s most historic bars and taverns. Guests enjoy drinks while hearing stories of ghosts, pirates, and unexplained encounters linked to the city’s nightlife.
➡️ Book Your Tour Here! 👻⬅️
Riding with the Ghosts: A Golf Cart Ghost Tour
Land and Sea Tours
This golf cart tour offers a comfortable way to explore haunted St. Augustine while covering more ground than a traditional walking tour. Guides share chilling stories and local legends as guests travel between some of the city’s most haunted locations.
➡️ Book Your Tour Here! 👻⬅️
The Last Stop Private Paranormal Investigation
Panda Tours
For those seeking a more personalized ghost hunting experience, this private investigation focuses on hands-on paranormal research in reportedly haunted locations. The small-group format allows guests to ask questions, use equipment, and conduct their own investigations throughout the evening.
➡️ Book Your Tour Here! 👻⬅️
Haunted Trolley Tour of St. Augustine
Ghosts and Gravestones
Known as one of the city’s most popular ghost tours, this experience combines a narrated trolley ride with exclusive stops at some of St. Augustine’s most infamous haunted locations. Guests hear tales of murder, tragedy, and restless spirits while traveling through the historic district after dark.
➡️ Book Your Tour Here! 👻⬅️
Haunted St Augustine FAQ
👻 Is St. Augustine the most haunted city in Florida?
Many people consider St. Augustine to be the most haunted city in Florida due to its long and often violent history. Founded in 1565, it is the oldest continuously occupied European settlement in the United States and has experienced wars, pirate attacks, disease outbreaks, and countless tragedies over the centuries. While cities like Key West and Ybor City also have strong paranormal reputations, St. Augustine is widely regarded as Florida’s premier haunted destination.
👻 What is the most haunted place in St. Augustine?
The St. Augustine Lighthouse is often considered the most haunted place in St. Augustine. Visitors and paranormal investigators have reported hearing children’s laughter, seeing apparitions, and capturing unexplained voices during investigations. The tragic drowning of three young girls during the lighthouse’s construction has helped make it one of the most famous haunted locations in the country.
👻 Are ghost tours in St. Augustine worth it?
Yes, ghost tours are one of the best ways to experience the haunted history of St. Augustine. Many tours combine historical facts with local legends, allowing visitors to learn about the city’s past while exploring some of its most haunted landmarks after dark. Whether you’re a skeptic, history lover, or paranormal enthusiast, a ghost tour offers a unique perspective on America’s oldest city.
👻 Can you visit the St. Augustine Lighthouse at night?
Yes, but only during select special events and guided experiences. The lighthouse regularly hosts paranormal investigations, moonlit tours, and seasonal nighttime programs that allow visitors to explore the property after dark. Because these events often sell out, it is recommended to reserve tickets in advance.
👻 Is the Old Jail really haunted?
The Old Jail is widely considered one of the most haunted locations in St. Augustine. Former employees, visitors, paranormal investigators, and ghost tour guides have reported hearing disembodied voices, footsteps, cell doors slamming, and seeing shadowy figures throughout the property. While there is no scientific proof that the jail is haunted, its reputation has made it a favorite stop for ghost hunters and paranormal enthusiasts.
Conclusion: Haunted St Augustine – 19 Creepy Places You Need To See!
With all there is to do in St. Augustine, you can sure you’ll be coming back again and again and not just for the chance to catch a ghost sighting! Whether your there to check out the beaches, experience the delicious local seafood and craft beer, or explore one of the oldest cities in the United States, there is just so much to do!
